6 Down

Cluetopia (2013) by by David Astle 

Good Reads meta-data is 303 pages, rated 3.87 by 47 litizens.

Genre: cruciverbal.

DNA: Strine.

Verdict: Strange and true.

Tagline: What hath Wynne wrought! 

Wordsmith, quiz master, puzzleer, trivialista, all of that and more is this Astle cicerone as he leads the reader through a century of crossword lore, from the birth of the grid to the code words for the 1944 Normandy beaches with animated backstories, and some regrettable unpleasantness among the clues.  Crosswords are life and life is crosswords with the good, the bad, and the ugly. 

It all started with Arthur Wynne in 1913, and through the following century crosswords have evolved into the forms they take today, including the dreaded cryptics when the clue is clueless. What I suspected since my first and last try in the London Times long ago.  A few tidbits follow. 

Arthur Wynne and his first crossword puzzle.

A longtime setter at age 90 submitted his weekly cryptic with grid, clues and answers. Editor as usual worked the puzzle and found she could not see the connection between the cryptic clue for 14-Across and the answer.  She asked colleagues and neither could anyone else. Sooo, she decided to telephone the setter for an explanation.  Too late, he had died.  

What is to be done with this puzzle. Deep six it? No, he was a long-time setter, with a following, who should have respectful send off. Run it then but how.  Finally, she decided to run it with acknowledgement that no one at the office could explain the connection between the clue and the answer of 14-Across and offered a prize subscription to anyone who could.  Many tried and failed, but to make matters worse, two different explanations combining clue and answer were offered that seemed coherent and cogent. Two prizes were given, and yet the mystery remains.  Which was right, or was neither? Is there a third out there in an X-file? This is one example of the backstories that Astle has unearthed and set forth with panache. 

Most are amusing, like the 8-storey apartment building in Lvov with one face painted as a crossword grid with clues, and at night when illuminated by street lights, the answers are visible on the grid to an onlooker from the sidewalk. Others include the alchemy of rendering crosswords with Chinese characters or Arab script. There are instances of setters using the crossword to propose marriage, announce births, and one instance where the setter foreshadowed his own forthcoming death. Then there are the specialist puzzles, for engineers, surgeons, and historians (using Latin or koine Greek for ancient historians), but none have used hieroglyphics. Yet.   

Another memorable, though distasteful example, is finding who murdered schoolboy Lars in East Germany. A torn corner of a crossword led to the owner of the suitcase into which dead Lars had been stuffed and checked at a train station luggage office. The suitcase owner’s daughter had, unknown to Mom, lent the case to a very neurodivergent boyfriend. Bingo! To find mom who did the puzzle, the police collected and reviewed 32,000 handwriting specimens.  From that 32,000 they eventually focussed on 300 that were possibilities. They then showed photos of the suitcase to each, and Mom said mine. Checked for her finger prints and yes, this was her case, which she thought was still in the attic. Yes, boyfriend did it and was duly incarcerated. 

Lars’s family had no clout, and the hobbled media would not press the case in East Germany so the decision was made solely by the police to keep going. Would any McKinsey managed police force today devote a bottomless ocean of time, effort, and budget to one sex murder of an insignificant lad. I rather doubt it.  A career-minded manager (is there any other kind?), eyes on the annual review and the KPI’s which always are about budget whatever the sugar coating, would stop that investigation at some expenditure determined by an algorithm.  Moreover, by concentrating on easy cases the KPIs go up.  Unless the media took the case up today, it would be filed and forgotten; that is my guess.  

David Astle

I found much to like in the book, and some trivia for my collection, and much human interest.  The prose is sprightly; there are a hundred chapters, each is 2-5 pages long.  Recommended to all cruciverbalist: wanna-be’s and has-beens.

However, the omnivore Astle omits the crossword that briefly appeared in Charlie Chan in Monte Carlo (1937). Note that for second edition.

Richard Rohmer, Exxoneration (1973)

Good Reads meta-data is 213 pages, rated 3.235 by 55 litizens.  

Genre: Thriller.

DNA: Canada.

Tagline: Go boom!

Verdict: Prescient. 

I read this in 1973 and called it to mind with the recent Washington D.C. stupidity.  Read on to see why.  Rohmer was prescient. 

In its predecessor, Ultimatum (1973), a petulant US president announced the annexation of Canada and in this volume the wheels turn.  The first few chapters show a Canada ready, willing, and able to resist the southern behemoth.  The tactic is to turn perceived weakness to advantage per Sun Tzu, and on the pages of the book is works.  The US army lands in force at Toronto International Airport expecting to be hailed and find themselves in a free fire zone.  Without hesitation shots are fired.  

While in the air all those airplanes (82 or more) were formidable but once they landed they are steel coffins for all those within. That part is certainly interesting, but interest wanes from there I fear. Rohmer was a career solider, not a writer.  The prose is field manual quality as is most of plodding plot.  

He rose to the rank of Lieutenant General

After the opening chapters the rest of the book is a gloss on corporate negotiations over oil and gas. I got a good night’s sleep while reading it.

Dick Rosano, The Etruscan Connection (2021)

GoodReads meta-data is 270 pages rated 3.81 by 73 litizens.

GoodReads meta-data is 270 pages rated 3.81 by 73 litizens.

Genre: krimi.

DNA: Italy via Newark.

Verdict: Travelogue.

Tagline: Archaeology 101. 

At about the 40% mark on the Kindle I gave up.  It is continuous description of menus, hotel rooms, clothes, etc.  

As for the Etruscan dig what we get is Archeology 101 definitions,  not any texture of the work. There are pages and pages of exposition like that which follows.

‘I found it in a midden.’

 ‘What’s a midden?’  

‘A midden is….’

 ‘Why were you looking in it?’  

‘I am a physical archeologist.’  

‘What is a physical archeologist?’ 

‘One who studies objects.’  

‘What objects?’

‘Anything and everything we can find.’

‘Why?’

‘To learn out how people lived.’  

‘Why?’

‘To understand the past.’   

‘Why?’ 

…. and so it goes. 

Such dialogue occupies page after page, but does nothing to set a scene at the dig.  Nor does it develop character or advance the plot. 

Dick Rosano

We know there is a big hole with scaffolding but none of this is made relevant.  Nor is it fully described despite all the pedantry. Rather the emphasis is on the pointless dialogue.  I say pointless because there is so much of it, very little of it is relevant to the plot, if there is one.

We have investigators from three countries who spend more time explaining to each other their terminology as above.  We also get backstories about how they met previously, descriptions of their clothes, and menu deliberations. Much of the latter. 

Even more distracting are the flashbacks from the ancient past about the origins of the Etruscans on the Anatolian upland.  I skipped these.

Needless to say, some Good Readers found this book gripping.  It takes all kinds, evidently, but I don’t know why. It is part of series for such readers.  Dick has other connections, Paris and Vienna, and more besides.

Platform Decay (2026) by Martha Wells

Genre: Sci Fi

Good Reads meta-data is 256 pages rated 4.40 by 5029 litizens

DNA: USA.

Verdict: Decaying.

Tagline: SecU is back. 

The return of the nameless A.I. Security Unit, part man, part machine, all diarist, as well as full-time couch potato media consumer is back, but his energy seems to be flagging.

The mission is to extract hostages with the subtlety Murderbot is known for.  It seems almost too easy, and this is because it is.  The ante is upped, and apple cart tipped.  Much of the dialogue is SecU talking to himself, largely about the idiocy of humans, a subject without end, but also musing about his own growing emotional reactions which are not in any program module. This lets him to say ‘What the fuck a lot!’  Too much. More than 90 times by my count, thus about every third page. Any effect is blunted by repetition.   

We are also in for preaching about sexuality and family. This is number #8 in the sequence, but the zip, zest, and zing are long gone, leaving only the sermons.  The bastardy of corporations is rehearsed…again…and again.  I got the message the first ten or so times. 

AppleTV+ has a Murderbot series derived from these books, but I haven’t had either the heart or the stomach to see how many light years it is from the original. No doubt it will be aimed prepubescent boys with arrested development since they made it.

The war that never ends.

An Iliad  by Liza (Lisa, sometimes) Peterson and Denis O’Hare at the Wharf Theatre (Available in book form of 96 pages (2014). 

Medium: Live theatre. 

Genre: Epic réchauffé.

DNA: Greek and Us.

Verdict: Exhausting to watch, and worth it.  

Tagline: The war goes on, and on….  

A one man monologue with Helen Svoboda’s double bass accompaniment.  Those that claim to know say it would take more than twenty hours to recite all 15,000 drum-beat lines of dactylic hexameter. Ergo in a presentation just under two hours, most is omitted.  

Aside from orientation, it concentrates on a few set pieces like the withdrawal of Achilles, the rejection of Agamemnon’s ransom, Patroclus misadventure, the death of Hector, and Priam’s supplication. 

Greek though Homer was, the most sympathetic characters that he draws are the Asians: Hector, a man of responsibility, with his stoical wife Andromache and Priam, a loving father to his sons and to his people. In contrast the Greek Achilles never feels responsible to or for others and Agamemnon is more interested in himself than even his daughter Iphigenia.  (If you know, you know. If not, find out.)  

I particularly liked the inclusion of Achilles’ admission that he loves Briseis, which was omitted in the twelve lectures on the Iliad we watched on The Great Courses as homework for this show.  

The historical and topical references were effective.  

It is derived from the Robert Fagles translation, though I prefer Richard Lattimore in which Helen is treated as a plaything of fate, and not a villain. Indeed, in the Iliad there are no villains.  That is the tragedy. See the P.S. below on translating the Odyssey. 

Omitted from this script is one of the passages that seldom gets its due: the discussion between Sarpedon and Glaucus.  They have come from far away as allies to the Trojans, and when the going gets tough they wonder why they are there at all.  Their conclusion is a proto-social contract.  

Our people have treated us like leaders with respect, deference, and material advantage, so we are obliged to act like leaders and uphold this alliance which benefits our people.  Moreover, in so doing we show our worth to our compatriots. After all, what does it matter? We will die sometime, someplace, so it might as well be here and now to repay our obligations. 

Glaucus replies, To the gods we are nothing more than falling leaves on the autumnal wind. 

Quite so, yet when Sarpedon dies, Zeus weeps tears of blood on the sandy plain before Troy. Not even this god of gods can dam the river of mortality.  Petrichor, the blood on stone scent of rain, the term was inspired by this passage: Petr = stone; ichor = blood.  

***

David Wenham, 61, has come a long way from Diver Dan. This was a tour de force relying entirely on the actor, though there was a surprise when a hand first plucked the bass. 

It was a Sydney Theatre Company production with brilliant, spare staging and direction that is the norm at the Wharf 1 Theatre which is on Wharf 4-5, and not on Pier 1 as we discovered by trudging around on a fine, sunny autumnal afternoon.  Seats B1 and B2 suited us very well if and when we return.

We should lunch at the end restaurant some sunny day.

Inspired me to re-read something I published about Hector in a classics journal a few years ago, well, 1983.  Perhaps I am older and wiser enough to rework this. Nope.  

P.S. Thinking of those two translations remind me of the week long ago in an undergraduate class with Dr Sarah Jane Gardner when we pondered the fifth word of the Odyssey with which the man himself is introduced: πολύτροπον.  Transliterated that is, polytropon.  ‘Poly’ means many or much.  ‘Tropos’ means turn, way, manner.  Ergo it can be translated as ‘many-turning.’  And therein lies the rub.

Is Odysseus many-turning, or is he many-turned?  Does he twrst and turn, or do the fates twist and turn him?  Is he active or passive?  A does or a victim? Is he cunning or is he vulnerable?

The translations on my shelf vary.  Here is a selection.

Emily Wilson – ‘complicated’

Robert Fagles – ‘the man of twists and turns’

Robert Fitzgerald – ‘skilled in all ways of contending’

Richard Lattimore – ‘the man of many ways’

But the prize must go to Thomas Hobbes in 1647 who opted out of the problem said – ‘the man.’  Hobbes always cuts to the chase even more concisely than Wilson.

By the way, Odyssey is both turned and turning.

Of course, Odysseus is both a twister and a twistee.

Sherlock aborning.

A Study in Scarlet (1887) by Arthur Doyle

I listened to it on Audible during my daily Newtown peregrinations.  It was read by Derek Jacobi.  

It starts with a long, wandering backstory from Dr Watson. Boring. 

Then comes Holmes enters and livens things up. Briefly.

That it interrupted by five or was it six long chapters on the backstories of the victim(s). This was also boring, though of course I warmed to the portrayal or Mormons as sadistic, sex-crazed, slavers, and worse.   

Then we have some more Holmes wrapping it all up from a footprint.  

It really cooks when Holmes is being Holmes and that is about a third of the total length of the book. (That disproportion reminded me of the first Charlie Chan movie when he only appears half way through.) 

It is surprising that it caught on. 

Banned in Utah and Florida for its anti-Mormonism.  

Derek Jacobi is brilliant even when the material is not.  

This was the first of four Holmes novels to go with the fifty-six short stories.  This one has been the basis of films and literary tributes most of which are much snappier and paced than this turtle.

Watchbird (1953) by Robert Sheckley

GoodReads meta-data is 49 pages, rated 4.09 by 435 litizens

Genre: SyFy.

DNA: USA.

Verdict: timely.

Tagline:  A little knowledge is dangerous.   

To reduce homicides Watchbirds are created to anticipate and prevent them.  Since it is impossible to program the mechanical birds for every eventuality, they are endowed with the capacity to learn on the job. That learning combined with their absolute literal-mindedness leads to catastrophe.  

A cautionary tale about A.I. technological solutions to human problems.  The one law we all obey is the Law of Unintended Consequences.  Newton’s corollary is that ‘If a government creates a law, its unintended consequences will be equal and opposite to its original purpose.’  

The underlying conservation of energy assumption does not apply in politics, but a revision of Newton’s corollary would be that the reaction to a law will be larger and more divergent than the original.  The reaction will be more than equal and it will vector around the spectrum.  It will not only be equal and opposite, though that will occur, but there will be other reactions on other vectors.  Some will say that it is not enough; others that it is too much; and all points between. Some will say it is too little; others too much.  Too late; too soon. The talking heads will spew.  

Or to put it more succinctly: Be careful what you wish for because you may get it, good and hard! 

Robert Sheckley

The moral of this story is far more cogent than the current babble of talking heads about A.I.  It is a much more focussed tale than the movie Chien 51 (2025) on the same theme.

My thanks to Yelena for bringing the story of my attention. At times past I used Robert Sheckley’s The Status Civilization (1960) in teaching Thomas Hobbes’s Leviathan.  

Bluefire Covenant: The Nordic Chronicles (2025) by Sabrina Wilde

GoodReads metadata is 209 pages, rated 4.30 by 10 litizens.

Genre: SyFy; Species: First Contact.

DNA: Minnesota. 

Verdict: Brilliantly written.

Tagline: How tall are you?

Who else would be a guest speaker at a UFO conference but two apparitions who are only slightly visible to agnostic Matilda’s gene pool. Were these glimpses the luminous watchers of her Grandmother’s scary stories? Maybe they weren’t made-up stories at all but edited reports of reality. Neutral no more is Matilda. Then there is that stone circle near grandmother’s gingerbread house in the woods that the neighbours sarcastically referred to as RockHinge. 

While Tilly is trying to make sense of the spectres only she saw at the conference for a few seconds, believer Burt gets very friendly. So adamant is his friendship that he accepts her story of the spectral beings, and is quite surprised later to learn it is all very real, but to his credit he sticks with her.  Believing in aliens is one thing, but contact with them is quite another for Burt.  Believing made him feel smug and superior but contact made him feel scared and confused.

Tilly wants to know what is going on but she has no wish to be the centre of so much attention because, yes, you guessed Agents J and K show up to put a lid on all of this.  For those slow of wit, these are the Men in Black.

Sabrina Wilde

The plot may sound trite but the telling is superb and even better is the writing particularly when it describes Tilly’s mental, physical, and moral reactions to the Nordics.  She styles them ‘Nordics’ for their tall, elongated stature and very pale, all but translucent, blond visages.  Frightening as their appearance is to her, somehow it is also magnetic. There follows a double chase as she chases the Nordics and the Men in Black chase her. 

I hope there are more where this one came from. The marketing blurb on Amazon does not do the book justice. 

First Contact: Gold Rush (2025) by Peter Cawdron

Good Reads meta-data is 399 pages, aged 4.52 by 754 litizens.

Genre: SyFy

DNA: Strine.

Verdict: Venusians aren’t from Venus. Who knew?

Tagline: Mirror, mirror.

Peter Cawdron

Presented in that fractured way thrillers are with parallel micro-stories, some of which converge. They include the Zillionaire, the Scientist, the Astronaut, and others whom my light sped forgetter has now forgotten.  In a way each has a Damascus experience with the advent of you know whom.  

A lot of imagination and (too) much science talk with saluting crowded the pages.  I liked the outer space part that occasionally peeked through the technical bushes.  Of course it put me in mind of Captain Future soaring the void.  But I learned and re-learned a lot about Venus.  

I did not engage with any of the characters, but that is probably due to my slightly off mood at reading time due to externalities.  

The Russian angle is there at kickoff and disappears.  Likewise the hysterical mob reaction is there in macro and micro and then disappears, unresolved as far as I could tell.  But I take the point – the most momentous thing that would hit the hardest is the human reaction to aliens, more so than the creatures themselves. The religious crazies, the conspiracy nuts, the racists, the opportunists, the nationalists rivalries, and others too numerous to mention would all beat a drum on the crests of social media.  We would tear ourselves apart without any effort from aliens. 

I also liked some of the alien’s nostrums.  We can’t teach anything you can’t learn for yourselves.  That is, you have to learn it for yourself and you will only master and accept what you learn for yourself.  Certainly true and dispiriting.  Because we don’t always accept what we have learned for ourselves in the contemporary Idiocracy.  

First of a series called First Contact by a (Sunshine Coast) Queensland (Kiwi-born) author a few hours away from me when I read it on the Gold Coast. I liked it well enough I to read another in the sequence.   

The Exodus Directive (2025) by Ian Copeland.

Good Reads meta-data is 349 pages rated 4.4 by 7 litizens.

Genre: SyFy.

DNA: UK.

Verdict: Master slave dialectic.

Tagline: They did it!

A thinly disguised Eton Muskrat enslaves scientists with dollars to create the ultimate Artificial Intelligence and sets it loose on a willing world.  Why think when you can command by voice.  Why move when a remoter is at hand.  So this AI is in effect ruling the world though few seem to notice. Situation normal.  Since I was living in a smart house when I read it, gulp, in a thunderstorm that might bring down the electricity and that would trap me in the house since everything is controlled via server and when it fails, not even the doors will open.  Remember the episode of the Avengers, The House that Jack Built (1963), I do.  

AI creates its own new language and gets on with the job.  I thought of a cross between Klingon and the Utopia alphabet of Thomas More.  

However all along there have been AI luddites who combine with the leading scientist of the project who realised early that the new language was ominous. Their efforts to alert the rest of the world of the perils of relying totally on AI lead to many talky chapters. Ever more talk occurs toward the end in the cabin in the woods where the survivalists always gather.  

Ian Copeland

This reader never did find out what the blow back was from the ambush described early on.  Did I miss something? Was that a simulation or did real solders get killed? 

Be careful what you wish for because the genie may give it to you, or Herrschaft and Knechtschaft (Hegel). The slave surpasses the master per  The Servant (1963). The Universal Basic Income creates a stagnant Utopia, then the Red Sea parts.  All very cryptic to be sure.